Shoeless Joe’s All-Star Hall of Shame Inc Our store is located in Cooperstown NY on Main Street across the Street from the National Baseball Hall of Fame.


Shoeless Joe Gloves,

Rawlings Gloves, Bats, Batting Gloves, Pants, Belts, Protective gear,

Mizuno Gloves, Bats, Batting Gloves)

Eye Black,

Ionic Gear

Sun Glasses


Apparel-Autographs-Cooperstown Gifts-Memorabilia (Weekly Specials)


Autographs from Baseball’s most famous players of yesterday and today

Baseball Cards

Licensed Photo’s Signed and Unsigned (MLB, NFL, NBA, NHL, TV, Movies, Music & Politics)

Children’s/Infant Apparel

Christmas Ornaments

Cooperstown T-Shirts

Cooperstown Gifts/Souvenirs


Display Cases

Fitted Caps (Adult, Child, Infant)



Old Yankee Stadium Seats

McFarlane Sports Figures

Movie, Music, TV Memorabilia


Mini Bats




Toys, Games, Puzzles…

Tin Signs

Street Signs

Shot Glasses

Vintage Baseball Fitted Caps

Who’s on First (Posters, Caps, Shirts, Jerseys, DVD’s, Mugs, Pint Glasses, Shot Glasses…)

We purchase and offer autographed memorabilia only from reputable, leading producers of authentic sports memorabilia and many of our autographs and other memorabilia have been authenticated by Major League Baseball and documented on the Major Leagues Baseball Web Site (MLB.Com) 

We are authorized distributors of the following Memorabilia companies:

All-Star Hall Of Fame Memorabilia of Cooperstown LLC ,

Global Authentics

Ironclad Authentics, 

Locker Room Memorabilia,

Mounted Memories

Steiner Sports,

Tri-Star Productions,

Upper Deck,



All autographed items come complete with a Certificate Of Authenticity (COA) and are fully guaranteed to pass inspection by James Spence Authentication and/or PSA/DNA.